Do you remember the good old days when toaster ovens were just…toaster ovens? They had a simple purpose and they did it well. But now, they have taken on a whole new life. In fact, many people are choosing retro toaster ovens as their appliance of choice – and for good reason!
These fun and trendy appliances come in a variety of colors, sizes, and styles, making them perfect for any kitchen and providing you with the nostalgia you're seeking. Plus, they offer all of the functionality of a regular oven – but in a smaller package!
How We Choose the Best for You
It can be hard to decide which is the best retro toaster oven for you, especially if you don't have time to read through hundreds of reviews. Who has time to read through all the reviews? You're busy! We get it.
So we've done the work for you and found the best six on the market. Whether you're looking for a small toaster oven or one with all the bells and whistles, we've got you covered.
Nostalgia RTOV2RR Retro Convection Toaster Oven
Large Capacity and Convection Bake
We Love It Because:
You love your old-school toaster oven, but it's just not big enough for all the cooking you want to do.
It's time to upgrade to the Nostalgia RTOV2RR Retro! This bad boy has such a large capacity you can put up to 12 slices of bread or 2 12-inch pizzas, and it comes with multi-functioning settings like bake, toast, convection bake, and broil and a 60-minute timer.
Plus, the adjustable temperature ranges from 200 to 450°F so you can cook whatever your heart desires. And if that wasn't enough, the 60-minute timer dings to alert you when cooking is completed so you never have to worry about overcooking again.
The Nostalgia RTOV2RR pictured is red, but you can also get it in aqua.
Last but not least, the clear-view window is a high temperature-resistant glass with stainless steel handle so you can keep an eye on your food without having to open the door.
What’s Good to Know
This Nostalgia offers so much versatility! It features an indicator light to show when it's on, and with its four-stage heating selections of Upper, Lower, Upper and Lower, you can customize your baking experience.
Need longer than 60 minutes? With the Stay-On feature, you can get extended baking time. The internal size measures 12x8x10 with plenty of room for all sorts of dishes.
Plus, the baking pan, wire racks, and crumb tray are removable for easy cleaning.
With a whopping 1500 Watts and a 1-year warranty, you're guaranteed a quality product that will last.
And one reviewer put it perfectly: "I have a retro kitchen so this toaster oven, along with the matching microwave I purchased to go with it, is perfect. They are designed beautifully and work well." What more could you ask for?
We Love It Because:
If you want a retro toaster oven that also serves as an air fryer, then look no further than the Deco Chef 24 Qt Stainless Steel Toaster Oven. It boasts an air fryer as well as a fry basket, rotisserie, grilling rack and a pan for baking.
This amazing appliance has all the best features of both a toaster oven and an air fryer, making it the perfect addition to your kitchen.
With 10 preset cooking modes and a digital interface, you can easily cook up a variety of your favorite foods.
Plus, the rotisserie feature is perfect for those times when you want to slow-cook a juicy chicken or roast a delicious pork loin.
And cleanup is a breeze thanks to the removable grill rack, frying basket, and baking pan.
Whether you're whipping up a quick snack or preparing a full meal, the Deco Chef is sure to make your cooking experience better than ever.
What’s Good to Know
If you're wanting a hassle-free, enjoyable cooking experience, then this air fryer could be right up your alley! Each piece is removable and dishwasher safe, so clean-up is a breeze.
Plus with internal dimensions of 13x12.36x8.75, you have roomier flexibility. But that's not all; the front clear-view window and an internal light let you see exactly how your food is coming along as it's cooking!
We suggest getting a heat-resistant silicon mat to place underneath it due to some heat release when air frying - many users swear by them!
Additionally, there's also a good safety feature; one customer stated: “When you open the front door, there is a little plastic black strip at the top edge. That little strip has saved me from burns a few times!"
With 1700 Watts on tap, you'll whip up delicious snacks and meals in no time - what more could you want?
We Love It Because:
This Galanz has a combination of settings so you can use it for toasting, baking, broiling, and even dehydrating. It also has a setting to keep your food warm. So if you desire a simpler retro toaster oven without the added air fryer, this one might just be your choice.
And with internal measurements of 12x8x10, there's plenty of room to cook whatever you're craving. Plus, with 2 rack positions, you can customize your cooking to perfection.
A 9x13-inch baking pan is a good size for most dishes and fits great if it doesn't have handles.
With so many great features and a retro look, the Galanz is a great value for any kitchen.
What’s Good to Know
If you’re looking for a convenient and easy-to-use oven that also looks amazing, then the 1500-watt retro oven is just what you need.
Not only is it incredibly easy to clean and operate, but it has powerful cooking capabilities, thanks to its superior convection technology.
Plus, the glass door allows you better visibility while you cook and the interior light helps you keep an eye on those delicious dishes.
Accessories are made with non-stick materials so that cleaning up after each meal is a breeze!
And if that’s not enough to make this oven your must-have kitchen item, it also comes in two fun colors - red and bebop blue.
All in all, this stylish appliance will give your kitchen a beautiful retro look and unbelievable convenience.
Hauswirt 26.5 Qt Extra Large Smart Air Fryer/Toaster Oven
Extra Large - Does It All!
We Love It Because:
Looking for an air fryer that can do it all? Look no further than the Hauswirt 26.5 Qt Extra Large Smart Air Fryer/Toaster Oven!
This versatile appliance can air fry, convection bake, rotisserie, dehydrate, and more. And it's extra large, so it's perfect for cooking large meals or multiple dishes at once. And you get eRecipes to try your cooking skills with new ideas.
Plus, it has a fast heating ability so you can get started cooking right away. And with its elegant enameled retro ivory color, it's sure to add a touch of style to your kitchen.
Best of all, it comes with a 24-month warranty so you can buy it with confidence.
What’s Good to Know
If you're looking for a user-friendly appliance to help you with your meal prep, look no further than this 26.5-quart capacity digital air fryer oven!
With both separate temperature control settings for top and bottom heating elements, you'll have perfect results in no time.
Included in the full set of accessories are rotisserie forks, a frying basket, a baking tray, racks, a drip tray, and oven mitts to make sure every cooking experience is safe and hassle-free.
With its internal capacity measuring 12x8x14 inches and 1200 watts of power - though it might take a few minutes to preheat - you can cook all your favorite dishes with ease.
And when you're done? Clean-up couldn't be easier. Go ahead and get ready for happy, healthy meals the whole family will enjoy!
Elite Gourmet Americana Retro Toaster Oven
True Vintage Art Deco Design with Enamel Coated Baking Pan
We Love It Because:
Start your day with a smile with the Elite Gourmet ETO1200BL Americana Retro Toaster Oven which is a mint blue.
This "vintage 50's diner" retro toaster oven is fun and perfect for any kitchen, and its compact size means it won't take up too much counter space. And the price won't break the bank.ut don't let its small size fool you - this little jewel can do it all! Whether you're baking, broiling, or toasting (4 slices at once), this little powerhouse can handle it.
Plus, it comes with an enamel-coated baking pan that is free of harmful chemicals like Teflon. So not only will your food taste great, but you can feel good about eating it too!
What’s Good to Know:
If you're looking for a baking buddy that won't take up much space and is inexpensive, this oven could be your match!
With a small capacity of 9.75x9.5x7.75 and 1300 watts of power, it's ready to help make your muffins or roasted potatoes in no time.
Plus, the built-in timer with an end-of-cycle buzzer will alert you when dinner is done. To sweeten the deal even further, accessories like a baking pan, wire rack, pan removal handle, and slide-out crumb tray are all included.
The only downside some customers have noticed is that the sides and top may become very hot during use - but if safety precautions are used like mitts and trivets, then this mini dynamo will be a great little addition to your kitchen!
We Love It Because:
SIMOE is the latest in retro-chic small kitchen appliances. The SIMOE Combo is a roomy and versatile 2-in-1 appliance that will make your cooking life easier than ever.
With 7 presets, 4 knobs for easy control, and a 19-quart capacity, this appliance can do it all.
The sleek stainless steel design with retro details will look great in any kitchen, and the removable crumb tray makes cleanup a breeze.
Whether you’re air frying, toasting, baking, roasting, broiling, or just warming up your food, the SIMOE has you covered.
So save yourself some counter space and choose the ultimate all-in-one appliance with the SIMOE Air Fryer Toaster Oven Convection Oven Combo.
What You Should Know
Who knew kitchen time could be so fun and carefree? An air fry basket, flat wire rack, broiling pan, and removable crumb pan give you the tools to enjoy delicious meals without stress.
With these four dishwasher-safe cooking accessories, you can cook with ease knowing that clean-up will be a breeze! Just pop them in the dishwasher and voila - no more scrubbing or soaking!
The reliable 12-month warranty ensures that you will not experience any surprises while using the 1550-Watt power.
Bertie's FAQ & Guide Section
Here are some really interesting Frequently Asked Questions we found while researching these awesome retro toaster ovens:
What should you not put in a retro toaster oven?
When it comes to using glass bakeware in small appliances, We have a warning: proceed with caution! Most bowls and dishes made from glass are not sturdy enough for the intense heat of countertop ovens and can shatter without notice. Save yourself some cleaning time (not to mention pain!) by opting for metal or ceramic containers instead.
What is the lifespan of a toaster oven?
It depends on the manufacturer. Some have a lifespan of around 10 years, while others may only last for around 5 years.
Toaster ovens can last longer if they're not used frequently. If you only use yours every once in a while, it'll probably last a lot longer than if you use it every day.
Another factor that affects the lifespan of one is how well you take care of it. Make sure to always unplug it after using it and never leave it plugged in when you're not using it. Also, keep an eye on the cord and make sure there aren't any frayed wires or anything else that could potentially cause a fire.
Do retro toaster ovens/air fryers need a heat-resistant mat?
It depends on the model. Some retro combinations come with a heat-resistant mat, while others do not. If your model does not come with a heat-resistant mat, you can purchase one separately. A good quality heat-resistant mat is important for protecting your countertop from burns and ensuring even heat distribution when using a retro toaster oven or air fryer.
Are air fryers just fancy toaster ovens?
No, air fryers are much more than just fancy toaster ovens. They are small appliances that use a hot air circulation system to cook food. This allows you to cook food with a minimal amount of oil, which results in healthier meals.
Additionally, because the food is cooked by hot air and not by direct contact with the heating element, there is less chance of your food becoming burnt or overcooked.
Is it OK to leave a retro toaster oven plugged in all the time?
No. It's not OK to leave one plugged in all the time. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) recommends that appliances be turned off when not in use, and that means unplugging them. This is because even when they're turned off, some appliances—including toaster ovens—continue to draw a small amount of current, or "phantom load." This phantom load can add up over time, so it's best to unplug them when you're not using them.
Why can't you put Pyrex in a toaster oven?
Pyrex is made from borosilicate glass, which is more heat-resistant than other types of glass. However, it can still break if it's heated too quickly or if it's subjected to a sudden change in temperature (such as when you take it out of the fridge and put it into a hot oven). That's why Pyrex is not recommended for use in toaster ovens - extreme temperatures can cause the glass to shatter.
Can parchment paper go in a toaster oven?
Yes! Parchment paper is oven-safe up to 420 degrees Fahrenheit, so it's perfect for toaster ovens. However, it's best not to use it if you are going to bake over 350 degrees. Just place the parchment paper on the baking sheet or rack and put your food on top of it. Enjoy!
Is it safe to use silicone bakeware in a toaster oven?
There's no definitive answer to this question since they vary so much in terms of their size, power, and design. However, most silicone bakeware is safe to use at temperatures up to 428 degrees Fahrenheit, so as long as your oven doesn't exceed that temperature, it should be safe to use silicone bakeware in it. Just be sure to check the manufacturer's instructions for your specific bakeware set to make sure.
Why do some frozen foods say no toaster oven?
Many frozen foods say "no toaster oven" because the high heat from this small appliance can cause the food to become dry, or even burned. Additionally, some frozen foods are meant to be microwaved instead of baked in a toaster oven.
Can you put Corelle in a toaster oven?
Yes, you can put Corelle in a toaster oven. It's important to use low heat and not overheat the dish, as this could damage it. Make sure to keep an eye on it while it's in the oven and remove it when it's done cooking.
Can you cook a cake mix in a toaster oven?
Yes, you can cook a cake mix in one depending on the size you choose. Make sure to follow the instructions on the cake mix box for baking time and temperature.
They do work best for smaller cakes, like 9x13 inch or 8x8 inch cakes. If you're using a larger cake pan, like a 9x13-inch cake pan, you may need to bake the cake in two batches. Enjoy!
So What's the Best Retro Toaster Oven for You?
Our selection of the best toaster ovens on the market today pays homage to both classic designs and modern features. For any budget, you can find a model with all the style and convenience your kitchen desires!
Whether it's an inexpensive appliance or one chock-full of bells and whistles, our review provides everything needed for making that perfect addition to your countertop.
Thanks for stopping by our bee hive!
Bertie
Each product we reviewed was independently selected by our team, and all opinions in this article are our own. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. We stay in business by receiving a small share of sales from the links on this page should you decide to buy something.
Member discussion